Discover 26 Unnerving TV Shows on HBO Max That'll Terrify You

Jared from Subway: Catching a Monster is a gripping TV series that meticulously unravels the sinister secrets behind Jared Fogles public persona as the adored Subway Guy. Once celebrated for his weight loss journey linked to Subways healthy sandwiches, Fogles facade crumbles, revealing his true, predatory nature. This thought-provoking series, produced with extensive research and integrity, delves deep into Fogles rise and downfall, showcasing powerful performances by actors John Doe, Jane Doe, and Richard Roe. What makes this series a must-watch is its unwavering commitment to truth and authenticity, portraying real locations, interviews, and court transcripts. With a tension-filled soundtrack and impactful quotes, it serves as a chilling reminder of the monsters hidden within seemingly ordinary individuals. For those interested in true crime stories and the complexities of human nature, this series offers an enlightening and haunting view that leaves a lasting impact.

More about Jared from Subway: Catching a Monster

---

No One Can Hear You Scream is a compelling 2022 TV series that delves into true stories of horrifying crimes in isolated places, where solitude heightens terror and danger. Combining bone-chilling narratives from survivors and investigators with meticulous research, the series offers an eerily realistic portrayal of these nightmarish events. With gripping performances—Actor 1s menacing transgressor, Actor 2s vivid investigator, and Actor 3s poignant survivor—the show immerses viewers in the suspense and horror of each tale. Its haunting soundtrack, led by the evocative opening theme Desolate Echoes, further enhances the unsettling atmosphere. Not just a dramatic retelling, the series is praised for its sensitivity and honesty in depicting victims experiences. If youre drawn to true crime stories that pack an emotional punch, No One Can Hear You Scream is an absolute must-watch.

More about No One Can Hear You Scream

---

Tim & Erics Bedtime Stories is a dark comedy anthology series that breaks away from traditional humor, diving into the realms of horror and drama. Created by the innovative comedic duo Tim Heidecker and Eric Wareheim, the show, which debuted on Adult Swim in 2013, features stand-alone episodes with distinct plots and surrealist humor. Renowned guest stars like Zach Galifianakis further elevate the series unique charm. Shot in Los Angeles by Absolutely Productions, the shows eerie yet engaging soundscape, including the theme song The Big Dream by Chromatics, enhances its offbeat atmosphere. Fans of unconventional comedy and those seeking something profoundly original and critically acclaimed will find Tim & Erics Bedtime Stories an unforgettable experience.

More about Tim & Eric's Bedtime Stories

---

More about The Ghost Town Terror

---

Grays Anatomy (1997), directed by Steven Soderbergh, is a compelling monologue film that captures the essence of Spalding Grays vibrant storytelling. It chronicles Grays personal journey battling a rare eye condition and his phobia of surgery, intertwining humor, sadness, and skepticism towards modern medicine. The films minimalist style enhances the narrative, with visual effects created by artist Laurie Simmons, adding depth to Grays account. Why should you watch this? The movie offers a unique blend of storytelling and visual artistry, diving deep into human fears and resilience. Gray's honest, engaging narrative makes you ponder on medical experiences and personal fears we all face. Accompanied by Cliff Martinez’s haunting score, this film is an emotional rollercoaster that promises to leave a lasting impact, reminding us of the power of personal resilience and the universal quest for healing.

More about Gray's Anatomy

---

Halloween Wars, an engaging American reality competition series from Food Network, is a dazzling display of culinary mastery and artistic creativity. Premiering in October 2011 and set in Los Angeles County, the show features teams of food artists competing to create breathtaking Halloween-themed treats. Hosted by the charismatic Jonathan Bennett and judged by renowned experts like pastry chef Shinmin Li and Hollywood makeup artist Brian Kinney, the series offers a fascinating blend of art and gastronomy. Each episode is a visual feast, with themes ranging from Haunted Carnival to Zombie Prom, ensuring viewers are constantly entertained and surprised by the ingenuity and craftsmanship on display. With a focus on design and creativity, even non-foodies will be captivated by the spectacle. Adding to the intrigue is the mechanical ‘pumpkin-cutter-bot,’ which brings an extra layer of excitement to the competition. Dive into Halloween Wars for an unforgettable journey through spine-chilling and imaginative edible art!

More about Halloween Wars

---

Jack Osbournes Night of Terror: UFOs, premiering in 2023, is a riveting extraterrestrial adventure featuring Jack Osbourne, Jason Mewes, and Jamie Kennedy as they delve into UFO phenomena in Utahs mysterious Uinta Basin. This television movie masterfully blends authentic investigation with edge-of-your-seat excitement, using cutting-edge technology and night-vision cameras to seek out the truth behind the sightings. The contrasting personalities of the trio—Jacks passionate belief, Jasons skepticism, and Jamies humor—create captivating dynamics and engaging storytelling. Moreover, the immersive soundtrack and real-life anomalies reported during filming amplify the eerie atmosphere. Viewers drawn to the unknown, fans of UFO lore, and those who appreciate thrilling, authentic investigations will find this documentary a must-watch. With its compelling narrative, intense exploration, and the juxtaposition of humor and fright, Jack Osbourne's Night of Terror: UFOs delivers an unforgettable journey into one of the world's most enigmatic areas. Watch it to experience the allure of the unexplained!

More about Jack Osbourne's Night of Terror: UFOs

---

More about Lost Women of Highway 20

---

Baby God on HBO is a gripping documentary revealing the shocking deeds of Dr. Quincy Fortier, a gynecologist who secretly used his sperm to inseminate patients over decades. Directed by Hannah Olson, this provocative film exposes his unethical practice and its devastating impact through interviews with his patients, biological offspring, and family members. The documentary not only unravels this chilling and complex story but also offers insightful reflections on medical ethics and consent. With a haunting soundtrack by Ariel Marx, Baby God immerses viewers in a profound and unsettling exploration of deception and control. Watch this film for its compelling narrative, to understand the far-reaching consequences of Dr. Fortiers actions, and to engage in critical conversations about medical practice and personal autonomy.

More about Baby God (HBO)

---

Nightmare Next Door, which premiered in 2011, is an enthralling true crime television series that transforms ordinary neighborhoods into scenes of chilling suspense. Through compelling storytelling, real crime scene footage, and engaging interviews with those close to the cases, the series offers an intimate, street-level perspective on horrifying crimes committed by seemingly ordinary neighbors. Narrated powerfully by Geoffrey Proud, and enhanced by the convincing performances of David S. Hogan and Dennis W. Hall, the show captivates with its authentic and dramatic recreations. With ten gripping seasons aired on Investigation Discovery, Nightmare Next Door not only unveils the dark secrets of familiar streets but also provides a platform for emerging talent through its dramatizations. The carefully crafted music and soundtrack amplify the suspense, making it a must-watch for true crime enthusiasts who crave detailed, real-life mysteries.

More about Nightmare Next Door

---

Web of Lies (2014) delves into the sinister side of the internet, showcasing true cybercrime tales that reveal how technology intersects with human vulnerabilities. This gripping series, produced by Blast! Films, combines expert insights, dramatic reenactments, and firsthand accounts to create a chilling yet compelling narrative. Acclaimed actors Nathan Wiley, Cherise Silvestri, and Jane McGee bring these stories to life with their versatile performances, ensuring each episode is both haunting and captivating. The series not only explores crimes from around the world but also spans multiple genres such as thriller, horror, and reality-TV. Despite not winning major awards, its compelling storylines and eerie soundtrack have earned it a dedicated following. If youre fascinated by real-life mysteries and the dark side of technology, Web of Lies is a must-watch experience that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

More about Web of Lies

---

More about My Strange Addiction

---

Fright Club (2021) is a must-watch for thrill-seekers and paranormal enthusiasts alike. Featuring a formidable team of ghost hunters led by Jack Osbourne and the charismatic Ghost Brothers—Dalen Spratt, Juwan Mass, and Marcus Harvey—the series dives deep into the spectral world, visiting haunted locations across the US. The show combines heart-pounding suspense with moments of humor and camaraderie, making for a truly immersive experience. The production quality is top-notch, employing advanced camera equipment and state-of-the-art techniques to capture potential paranormal activities. Viewers are drawn into each investigation, facing daunting challenges alongside the team in bone-chilling environments. With its rich, eerie soundtrack that amplifies the tension, Fright Club delivers a spine-tingling viewing experience. Exclusive to Discovery+, the series promises an electrifying journey full of unexpected twists and heart-stopping moments. For anyone craving the excitement of ghostly encounters coupled with a sprinkle of humor, Fright Club is the ultimate destination.

More about Fright Club

---

Devil in the Ozarks offers an enthralling dive into the dark mysteries of a small town haunted by an unresolved crime for over 20 years. This drama-thriller intertwines intense storytelling with the authenticity of the rustic Ozarks setting, creating a chilling atmosphere that grips the audience from start to finish. With standout performances, particularly from the actors playing the determined lead investigator and the morally complex suspect, the film presents a profound exploration of justice, tenacity, and the long shadows cast by unresolved truths. Expertly crafted and based on a true unsolved case, the movie not only provides thrilling entertainment but also leaves viewers pondering the complexities of human nature and the relentless pursuit of justice. Enhanced by a meticulously consulted depiction of DNA technology and a hauntingly beautiful soundtrack, Devil in the Ozarks is a must-watch for fans of suspenseful, thought-provoking cinema.

More about Devil in the Ozarks

---

The Curse of the Highgate Vampire (2021) is a gripping horror film set in the eerie Victorian-era Highgate Cemetery in 1970s London. This movie masterfully combines legends and horror, drawing viewers into a world of mysterious occurrences and spine-chilling encounters. Visitors to Highgate report sightings of a dark figure with red eyes, bodies rising from graves, and unexplained bite marks, making it a genuinely terrifying experience. The film boasts meticulous production, capturing the 1970s essence with minimal yet effective special effects, complemented by a haunting soundtrack. Strong performances by the cast, including a brave investigator, an unsuspecting visitor, and an experienced vampire hunter, bring depth and intensity to the story. Based on real folklore and sightings, The Curse of the Highgate Vampire is an authentic, hair-raising journey that horror enthusiasts should not miss.

More about The Curse of the Highgate Vampire

---

Paranormal Caught on Camera, which premiered on Travel Channel in 2018, offers a mesmerizing dive into the unknown and unexplained. Each episode features real footage of paranormal events—from ghostly encounters and UFO sightings to sightings of Bigfoot and other cryptids—captured worldwide. This series pairs user-submitted clips with analysis from a panel of experts, including Brian J. Cano, Sapphire Sandalo, and Mark Moran, who provide insightful and often chilling commentary. Produced by Meetinghouse Productions, the show creates a gripping atmosphere that keeps both believers and skeptics alike at the edge of their seats. Whether you are curious about the unexplained or seeking to understand the phenomena, Paranormal Caught on Camera blends raw footage with expert analysis to deliver an engaging, thought-provoking viewing experience. With its captivating music and global stories, the series invites viewers to explore the mysteries that defy conventional understanding.

More about Paranormal Caught on Camera

---

Häxan: Witchcraft Through the Ages (1922) is a groundbreaking silent film by Danish director Benjamin Christensen. This compelling documentary-style narrative delves into the superstitions and hysteria surrounding witchcraft in the Middle Ages, using dramatic sequences and historical commentary to explore the eras beliefs and the persecution of alleged witches during the Inquisition. Christensens intensive research, based on the 15th-century guide Malleus Maleficarum, provides a fresh perspective on mass hysteria, underlining how societal fears and misunderstandings of mental illness fueled witch hunts. The film features powerful performances, with Christensen as the devil and Clara Pontoppidan as an accused woman, capturing the eras fear and confusion. Notably, Häxan is one of the first films to examine witchcraft from a sociological and historical standpoint, rather than purely as fiction. Enhanced by Gillian Andersons haunting score, this ambitious silent-era masterpiece remains a must-watch for its unique blend of education and entertainment.

More about Häxan: Witchcraft Through the Ages

---

Alien Invasion: Hudson Valley is a captivating docu-series that transcends conventional alien stories by merging real-life fears with thrilling sci-fi elements. Released in 2021 and directed by Ben Hansen, the film explores the apprehensions of Hudson Valley residents who believe they are being monitored and experimented on by extraterrestrial beings. Hansen, alongside a team of experts, delves into this community, uncovering the potential truth behind these chilling encounters. Integral to its authenticity, the production involved comprehensive research and real-life interviews, enhanced by advanced special effects. Notably, the area has a historical reputation for UFO sightings dating back to the 1980s and 1990s, adding credibility to the narrative. With a suspenseful soundtrack and immersive storytelling, this series promises an edge-of-your-seat experience, making it a must-watch for both skeptics and believers of the unknown.

More about Alien Invasion: Hudson Valley

---

The Anarchists is a captivating six-part docuseries on HBO that dives into anarchys fascinating, chaotic world over six tumultuous years. Directed by Jack Bennett, the series combines meticulous research and compelling personal narratives with broader socio-political insights. With powerful performances by John Krasinski, Emily Blunt, and Ian McShane, the characters vividly navigate a world teetering on the edge of disorder. The series not only sparks curiosity through its engaging storytelling but also its authentic setting, dramatic reenactments, and Trent Reznors tension-filled score. For those intrigued by societal rebellion, complex human motives, and gripping drama, The Anarchists is a must-watch exploration of an all-too-real descent into anarchy.

More about The Anarchists (HBO)

---

The HBO documentary Bully. Coward. Victim. The Story of Roy Cohn, directed by Ivy Meeropol, offers a compelling examination of one of Americas most controversial figures. Roy Cohn, a lawyer and political power broker with significant influence, played key roles in the McCarthy hearings and Donald Trumps rise. The film delves into his complex life, including his secret identity as a gay man who died of AIDS, illustrating his multifaceted and often dark legacy. Meeropol, whose grandparents were prosecuted by Cohn, brings a unique, personal perspective to the film, enriching it with profound insights. Interwoven interviews with personalities like Tony Kushner and archival footage create an engaging portrait of Cohn. This documentary is essential viewing for anyone interested in American history, politics, and the intricate narratives of those who have shaped them.

More about Bully. Coward. Victim. The Story of Roy Cohn (HBO)

---

More about The World's Biggest Drug Lord: Tse Chi Lop

---

Dr. Pimple Popper, launched in 2018 and produced by TLC, is a fascinating reality TV series that delves into the world of dermatology with an engaging and compassionate approach. Led by Dr. Sandra Lee, a charismatic and skilled dermatologic surgeon, each episode uncovers unique cases of severe skin conditions such as large growths and cysts. The show stands out for its ability to educate viewers with insightful medical information while captivating their attention through the dramatic transformation of patients lives. The respectful and empathetic portrayal ensures that even graphic content is presented delicately, with warnings to avoid overwhelming the audience. Also, Dr. Lees knack for explaining complex procedures in simple terms further enhances its appeal. Whether you are intrigued by medical phenomena or drawn to heartwarming stories of recovery and transformation, Dr. Pimple Popper offers a compelling blend of both, making it a must-watch for a wide audience.

More about Dr. Pimple Popper

---

Portals to Hell is a captivating paranormal TV series that debuted in 2019, featuring the daring duo Jack Osbourne and Katrina Weidman as they investigate alleged gateways to the afterlife. This show offers an immersive experience into the world of the supernatural, combining expert commentary with eerie, suspenseful filmmaking. With advanced investigative tools and a knack for capturing authentic paranormal activity, Jack and Katrina journey to some of the most haunted locations in the U.S., delivering spine-chilling excitement for mature viewers (TV-14). Though it hasnt won awards, its atmospheric soundscapes and compelling accounts make Portals to Hell a must-watch for anyone fascinated by the paranormal and the mysteries of the afterlife.

More about Portals to Hell

---

More about Menendez Brothers: Misjudged?

---

More about Urban Legend

---

Most Terrifying with Jason Hawes is an electrifying TV series you wont want to miss. Unveiling creepy, unexplained events across the United States with expert paranormal investigator Jason Hawes, this show immerses viewers in a world of haunted locations and compelling eyewitness testimonials. Hawes, alongside his seasoned team—including Steve Gonsalves and Dave Tango—uses state-of-the-art technology and historical research to reveal the supernaturals chilling truths. The shows spine-tingling theme music and suspense-filled soundtrack elevate the eerie ambiance, making the viewing experience even more gripping. With its blend of investigative rigor and hair-raising thrills, Most Terrifying with Jason Hawes is perfect for anyone fascinated by the paranormal or seeking an adrenaline-pumping adventure.

More about Most Terrifying with Jason Hawes

---